Separating Truth from Hype: The Medicare Supplemental Insurance Plan

Let’s be honest—most people don’t really get how Medicare works until they’re staring at a deadline or getting close to retirement. And even then, it’s not simple. There’s Original Medicare, Part D, Medicare Advantage, and then there are Medicare Supplement Plans (also called Medigap).

Image by Freepik

Everyone's got opinions, stories, and “my neighbor told me…” kind of advice. But when it’s your health, it’s worth getting the facts straight. In this blog, we’ll discover what Medicare Supplement Plans really are and clear up some common myths.

What Is a Medicare Supplement Plan?

So here’s the basic idea without the fluff:

Original Medicare (Parts A and B) pays for a lot, but not everything. You’ll still have out-of-pocket costs—like deductibles, co-pays, and coinsurance. A Medicare Supplement Plan steps in to help cover those gaps. It’s private insurance that works with Medicare, not instead of it.

Let’s put it in a table to make it clearer:

Original Medicare	With a Medicare Supplement Plan
You pay hospital deductibles	Plan covers some or all of those costs
No out-of-pocket maximum	Helps limit your extra medical bills
Can see any doctor accepting Medicare	Same freedom, no network required
Doesn’t include drug coverage	Still need a separate Part D plan

So if you don’t want surprises when bills come, this kind of plan helps.

The Myths That Keep Going Around

People share a lot of bad info. Here are some things we keep hearing—and why they’re not exactly true.

Myth 1: “Medicare Advantage and Medigap are the same.”

Nope. Medicare Advantage Plans are a different thing altogether. They replace your Medicare benefits with a private insurance plan. That usually means networks, referrals, and local service areas.

Medigap keeps you on Original Medicare—it just pays for the parts that Medicare doesn’t.

Myth 2: “I can buy a supplement plan anytime.”

Technically? Yes. But if you wait too long, companies can say no or charge you more based on your health. There’s a 6-month window after you enroll in Medicare Part B when they have to accept you, no questions asked.

Myth 3: “All plans are the same, so pick the cheapest one.”

Not really. While Plan G or Plan N offer the same coverage no matter who sells them, the price can vary. One company might raise rates more often than another. It pays to look beyond just the premium amount.

Reasons Why Some People Choose Medigap Over Advantage

Different strokes for different folks. But here’s what some folks in St. Louis say they like about going with a medicare supplement agent and choosing a Medigap plan:

• Less fine print – No need to worry if a doctor is “in-network.”

• More predictable costs – You know your monthly premium, and many things are covered fully.

• Travel friendly – If you spend winters in Arizona or travel a lot, Original Medicare + Medigap follows you around.

Stuff You Might Want to Ask Before Choosing

Choosing a plan isn’t just about who advertises the most or what your neighbor picked. Here’s some stuff to ask:

• How often does the premium go up?

• What happens if I move to another state?

• Is the plan issue-age rated or community rated?

• Will this still work for me if I need specialist care in a different city?

And here’s a big one—ask how a Medicare broker helps to save money. Spoiler: They can compare different companies and plans without you having to make 15 phone calls.

So, Should You Choose Medigap or Advantage?

There’s no one-size-fits-all. But here's a little breakdown:

Medigap	Medicare Advantage
Monthly premiums, fewer surprises	Lower premiums, more cost-sharing
No network restrictions	Often includes networks and referrals
Separate drug plan needed	Usually includes drug coverage
Good for frequent travelers	May not cover outside local area

You get the idea. It depends on how much flexibility you want, how often you go to the doctor, and how much risk you’re okay with.

What If You’re Still Not Sure?

That’s normal. Most people don’t figure it out in one sitting. If you’re the type who likes to read every line before deciding, you’re not alone.

Working with a Medicare broker (not a salesperson) means you get help from someone who knows the ins and outs—without trying to push one company over another.

These folks look at your health, your lifestyle, and your budget, and walk you through the options. And they usually don’t charge you anything to do it.

Final Thoughts 

Medicare isn’t simple. And it’s okay if you don’t get it all the first time. Whether you end up choosing Medicare Advantage Plans, Medigap, or something else entirely—it should be your choice, not based on hype or pressure.

A lot of people in St. Louis feel overwhelmed at first. But once they take time to understand their options—and maybe sit down with someone like Scott Joyce, Medicare agent—they walk away feeling like they finally got a handle on it.

And that’s really the point. Not just picking a plan, but feeling confident you picked it for the right reasons.